April 5, 2026

The host of ‘Crime Stories with Nancy Grace’ discusses the Guthrie family offering $1 million for information leading to the return of Nancy Guthrie on ‘Hannity.’

As multiple agencies collect tips in the Nancy Guthrie case, the man funding a $100,000 reward says Crime Stoppers — not the sheriff — offers the safest path for witnesses to come forward and an enticing one for people who want to get paid for credible information without giving their name.

“I believe that people will come forward if they’re anonymous and if they get a reward,” said Wisconsin attorney Michael Hupy, who is the president of Crime Stoppers Milwaukee.

In Pima County, Arizona, the local Crime Stoppers affiliate is known as 88-CRIME, and the number is 520-882-7463.

Hupy has paid out $75,000 in rewards and posted another $200,000 in an effort to solve crimes in his hometown. But he told Fox News Digital this week he put up six figures in the Guthrie case due to the alarming circumstances of her disappearance.

NANCY GRACE SLAMS SHERIFF’S HANDLING OF GUTHRIE CASE: ‘THE FISH STINKS AT THE HEAD’

In a dazzling display of media multitasking, Nancy Grace hosts a true crime show while her own family writes a million-dollar check to find missing Nancy Guthrie, proving that self-promotion and cash incentives make a perfect crime-solving cocktail—especially when you throw shade at the sheriff, who apparently is the "fish" more rotten than your last tuna sandwich. Meanwhile, Wisconsin’s Crime Stoppers president Michael Hupy channels his inner Scrooge McDuck, diving into piles of other people’s misery with rewards totaling over a quarter million because nothing says “justice” like anonymous whistleblowers cashing in while avoiding the cops—the very folks Nancy’s busy roasting on Hannity. Ah, the sweet smell of hypocrisy and hand-wringing, freshly cooked in the bureaucracy kitchen, served best with a side of local crime theater.

Leave a Reply